Department of Labor Retirement Security Rule: Impact on Investors

Hiring a financial advisor is one of the most important steps you can take in your retirement planning journey. However, many times, there are conflicts of interest, and you cannot be entirely certain that the advice you get is legit or not. A retirement investment advisor may not always act in the best interest of their clients, which can lead to poor advice, compromised financial goals, and a shoddy financial future. The government has come up with some measures, such as the Department of Labor Retirement Security Rule, which helps protect the financial interests of clients and regulates the standard retirement advice professionals offer.

If you are considering hiring a financial advisor for retirement planning services, you must first understand the Retirement Security Rule. This article will help you understand the details of the new rule, what it entails, and its impact on financial advisors and retirement savers to help you make better decisions about your retirement planning needs.

Understanding the Department of Labor Retirement Security Rule

On April 23, 2024, the U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) introduced a new rule called the Retirement Security Rule. The new rule aims to reshape the regulatory framework around financial advice for workplace retirement plans, like the 401(k)s and Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs). This rule updates the definition of who is considered a fiduciary and introduces stricter fiduciary standards for investment professionals to ensure minimal conflicts of interest with retirement investors.

The Retirement Security Rule, also called the Final Rule, has been primarily introduced to redefine the definition of a fiduciary. The rule aims to ensure that professionals providing investment advice are acting in the best interests of their clients and helping them save for retirement without any conflicts of interest. Under the new rule, many financial professionals, including banks, broker-dealers, and insurance companies, will be required to follow fiduciary standards when offering investment advice for workplace retirement plans like the 401(k) and IRAs. The rule goes into effect on September 23, 2024, although some provisions related to Prohibited Transaction Exemptions (PTEs) will be implemented a year later.

Here are the key fiduciary responsibilities as mentioned under the new rule:

Financial advisors must provide investment recommendations that are prudent to their clients. They must consider the investor’s specific financial situation, goals, and risk tolerance to recommend investments that are suitable and in their best interest.
The rule requires financial advisors to be transparent about the fees and make sure that the investments they recommend protect retirement investors from conflicts of interest. They must ensure that their clients fully understand what they are paying for.
Financial advisors are required to implement and follow specific policies and procedures designed to ensure that the investment advice they provide aligns with the investor’s best interests.
Charging fair and reasonable fees is a crucial element of the fiduciary standard. Financial advisors are prohibited from overcharging for their services and must ensure that any fees associated with the advice they provide are justified.
Conflicts of interest must be carefully managed, and financial advisors are now required to disclose them to investors. This includes providing basic information about how the financial advisor’s compensation or other interests may influence the advice provided.

Prior to this rule, the DOL used a more limited five-part test developed in 1975 to determine whether a financial professional qualified as a fiduciary under the law. This test required financial advisors to meet several specific criteria, such as providing investment advice on a regular basis, for their actions to be deemed fiduciary in nature. As a result, many financial advisors, especially those who offered one-time advice or recommendations, were able to escape fiduciary obligations. However, the DOL acknowledged that the financial landscape has dramatically evolved since 1975. With the rise of IRAs and defined contribution plans, like 401(k)s, an increasing number of individual investors are taking on more responsibility for managing their retirement savings. Given this shift, the DOL has updated the fiduciary rule to protect retirement investors better and ensure that any professional who provides advice in exchange for a financial reward must act in the best interests of their clients.

It is worth noting that the DOL’s fiduciary rule bears similarities to the Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) Regulation Best Interest (Reg BI), which has been applied to broker-dealers since 2020. Reg BI requires broker-dealers to act in the best interest of their clients when making investment recommendations to retail investors. However, the DOL’s rule goes further by expanding the fiduciary standard to a broader group of financial professionals, such as banks and others, as well as to retirement plans. This means that financial professionals who may have previously been exempt under Reg BI but who work with retirement accounts will now need to adhere to the DOL’s stricter standards.

Changes to Prohibited Transaction Exemptions (PTEs)

A key component of the new Retirement Security Rule involves changes to PTEs, including PTE 2020-02, which is called ‘Improving Investment Advice for Workers and Retirees’. This exemption allows investment professionals who are classified as fiduciaries to provide advice to retirement plan participants while still receiving compensation, which might otherwise be prohibited, as long as they meet specific conditions. Since the new rule expands what counts as fiduciary advice, PTE 2020-02 will become even more important for investment professionals who want to continue earning fees while complying with fiduciary standards. Here are some of the changes made to PTE 2020-02:

Online-only advice: The exemption now covers financial advice provided through online platforms and not just through live representatives, so that digital advice services can qualify under this exemption.
Pooled plan providers: The changes now allow pooled plan providers to give fiduciary investment advice.
Disclosure updates: The rules require clearer disclosures about timing, compensation, and conflicts of interest.
Self-correction: Investment professionals who violate PTE 2020-02 can fix certain errors on their own, without having to report them to the DOL, under updated self-correction procedures.

Industry reaction to the Retirement Security Rule

The Retirement Security Rule by DOL has faced mixed reactions, with some groups welcoming the changes while others opposing it. Some argue that the new fiduciary definition could reduce access to affordable financial advice. This can make it harder for people to hire quality financial advisors, as professionals may choose to limit their services to avoid any liabilities or trouble with the regulations.

The American Council of Life Insurers (ACLI) has stressed that the rule is unnecessary because there are already strong protections for investors under existing regulations. They point out that the SEC Regulation Best Interest (Reg BI) and the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) are already sufficient to protect investors and that adding another layer of regulation, like the DOL’s rule, could create unnecessary complexity and duplication. The National Association of Insurance and Financial Advisors (NAIFA) has also expressed their concern about the Retirement Security Rule’s redundant regulations. They have highlighted that professionals in the industry are already held to high standards under existing laws, and the new rule could lead to confusion without offering significant new benefits to investors.

However, several organizations have also come out in support of the rule. For instance, the Certified Financial Planner (CFP) Board has expressed its support and stressed how the final rule aligns with investor expectations and establishes clear fiduciary standards for advisors to act in the best interests of those saving for retirement. Additionally, according to the Economic Policy Institute, the rule provides an essential safeguard for retirement investors who seek professional advice. The organization believes the new fiduciary standards will help ensure that investment professionals prioritize their clients’ interests over personal financial incentives.

It is important to note that the rule will be fully implemented from September 23, 2024. Some additional adjustments are expected to take effect in 2025, which means there could be further changes to the rule in the future.

Impact on investment advice

The new Retirement Security Rule is likely to bring respite to retirement investors by reducing conflicts of interest. It ensures that financial advisors act in the best interests of their clients and do not simply push products that earn them higher fees without considering what is in the best interest of their clients.

Moreover, the new rule is more pertinent to the present financial advisory industry. The landscape of retirement savings has changed significantly over the past few decades. In 1975, when the original five-part test was introduced, defined benefit plans were more common. These plans were typically managed by professional investment managers. Individual investors had little say in their investment choices and did not have to worry about managing their retirement funds. Today, defined contribution plans, like 401(k)s, are the norm, and they give individuals more control over their retirement investments. With the rise of such accounts, people are now making more direct investment decisions, which is why the DOL has updated the fiduciary rule to ensure that financial professionals are held to high standards and individual investors are able to enjoy a more simplified retirement planning process.

The Retirement Security Rule is likely to reshape how investment advice is provided to retirement savers significantly. It will bring with it a strict set of standards aimed at protecting investors from biased advice. Financial advisors, broker-dealers, and other investment professionals must now follow these rules of conduct to ensure that the advice they provide is truly in the best interest of their clients.

In essence, the Retirement Security Rule makes it clear that financial professionals who provide investment advice related to retirement accounts must prioritize their client’s best interests at all times. This rule ensures that retirement savers receive advice that is not only transparent and fair but also designed to help them reach their long-term retirement financial goals.

To conclude

The Department of Labor Retirement Security Rule is likely to make a massive difference in how the financial advisory industry works, especially in the case of retirement planning. With financial professionals adhering to stricter fiduciary standards, retirement investors can expect unbiased advice. The rule safeguards the interests of individual investors and places greater responsibility on the financial advisor to ensure that all professionals act in the best interest of their clients. These new measures can certainly contribute to reducing conflicts of interest and enhancing the overall integrity of retirement planning. However, as the rule takes effect in September 2024, both investors and financial professionals will need to understand the implications of these changes, particularly in how they impact investment advice and compensation structures.

Use the free advisor match tool to get matched with seasoned financial advisors who can help guide you on how the new rule impacts your retirement planning. Answer some simple questions about your financial needs and get matched with 2 to 3 advisors who can best fulfill your financial requirements.