When Should You Opt to File for Social Security Benefits?

The decision to file for Social Security benefits is one of the most pivotal financial choices many Americans will make in their lifetime. For countless individuals, Social Security serves as a foundational component of retirement income, often bridging the gap between personal savings and the costs of living in one’s later years. Yet, as straightforward as it may seem to simply claim benefits when one reaches a certain age, the landscape of Social Security is riddled with complexities and nuances. Determining the optimal time to start receiving benefits isn’t a one-size-fits-all answer; it varies considerably based on individual circumstances, goals, and needs. You may consider consulting with a professional financial advisor who can guide you on a suitable time for claiming your Social Security benefits.

In this article, we’ll delve deep into these considerations, aiming to facilitate insights needed to make an informed decision about the best time to claim Social Security benefits.

Understanding the basics of Social Security benefits

Before diving into the intricacies of when to file for Social Security benefits, it helps to grasp some fundamental concepts that govern this system. The intersection of these fundamentals with individual life scenarios, financial needs, and long-term goals determines the best time to file for Social Security benefits.

Below are a few Social Security fundamentals to understand before you file for your benefits:

1. Full retirement age (FRA)

At the heart of Social Security’s structure is the concept of Full Retirement Age or FRA. Simply put, FRA is the age at which an individual is eligible to claim 100% of their retirement benefit. It’s crucial to note that your FRA is not a fixed number; it largely depends on the year of your birth. For instance, for those born in 1937 or earlier, the FRA is 65. However, for anyone born after that, the FRA gradually increases. By the time we reach those born in 1960 or later, the FRA settles at 67.

2. Early and late filing options

While the FRA serves as a reference point, the Social Security system offers flexibility in terms of when you can start claiming your benefits. You can choose to file as early as age 62. However, doing so means accepting a reduction in your monthly benefits. On the flip side, if you decide to delay your benefits beyond your FRA, you’ll be rewarded with delayed retirement credits, which will increase your monthly benefits. This increase continues until age 70, after which there’s no additional benefit to waiting.

4 factors to consider when deciding to file for Social Security benefits

The decision of when you should opt to file for Social Security benefits is multi-faceted, involving a mix of personal circumstances and broader statistical considerations. Here, we discuss several essential factors you should consider before making this decision.

1. Present financial situation

Your immediate financial situation is a primary consideration when deciding whether to claim social security. If you have a dire need for immediate cash flow, opting for early benefits could be a lifesaver. On the flip side, if you have other sources of income or savings, delaying benefits to accrue more substantial monthly payouts in the future might be a better strategy.

2. Life expectancy

Longevity plays a crucial role in the decision to claim social security. If you come from a family with a history of living into their late 80s or 90s, delaying benefits could pay off in the long run. Conversely, if your health is compromised or your family history suggests a shorter lifespan, claiming the benefits earlier might be advantageous.

3. Marital status

Social Security isn’t just about individual benefits. Your decision can also affect your spouse. Spousal benefits allow one partner to claim a fraction of the other’s benefit, making it essential to consider both lifespans and needs. Additionally, those who are divorced but were married for at least ten years might be eligible for ex-spousal benefits. If a spouse passes away, the surviving partner might be able to claim survivor benefits, which may change the timeline of when they can claim the benefits.

4. Employment status

If you’re still working and are thinking about claiming benefits before your full retirement age, it is recommended to exercise caution. Earnings above certain thresholds can result in a temporary reduction of your Social Security benefits. However, once you reach your FRA, these earnings no longer affect the benefits you are entitled to.

Reflecting on the factors above, can provide clarity and help ensure you make a choice that aligns with your individual circumstances and long-term goals. It may also be worthwhile to consult a financial advisor who can devise a strategy based on your personal goals, needs, and financial resources.

What happens when you claim your Social Security benefits early?

One of the most significant consequences of early filing is that it results in a permanent reduction in your monthly Social Security benefits. This isn’t just a temporary decrease for the initial years; the reduction stays with you for the rest of your life. The earlier you begin, the bigger the cut. For many, this means thousands of dollars less over a lifetime.

Here’s an example to understand this impact better. Suppose Melissa, who was born in 1958, has a Full Retirement Age of 66 years and 8 months. If her monthly benefit at FRA is $2,000, but she decides to start taking benefits at 62, she would face a reduction of approximately 27.5%. That means, instead of the $2,000 she would have received monthly at her FRA, she would only receive about $1,450 every month. Over a decade, this decision could result in a shortfall of over $66,000.

The gravity of such decisions underscores the importance of careful planning and evaluation of one’s individual circumstances. While there might be valid reasons to take benefits early, understanding the long-term financial implications helps to assess whether it is worthwhile to explore other options to fulfill your immediate financial needs.

How can you benefit from delaying claiming your Social Security benefits?

While the prospect of early benefits might sound appealing to some, there are certain financial advantages in holding off until after your full retirement age.

One of the incentives for deferring your Social Security benefits is the opportunity to earn delayed retirement credits. These credits increase your monthly benefits for every month you delay, from the time you reach your full retirement age until you start claiming or until you reach age 70. This can result in a significant boost in your monthly payment.

Here’s an example to understand this better. Suppose Chris, born in 1960, has a Full Retirement Age of 67. If his expected monthly benefit at FRA is $2,500 but he chooses to delay his benefits until age 70, he can accumulate DRCs that could increase his monthly amount by 24%. So, instead of receiving $2,500, Robert would get approximately $3,100 every month. Over 10 years, this decision could lead to additional earnings of $72,000.

Another advantage of waiting is that the larger monthly benefits you receive from delaying might also lead to bigger cost-of-living adjustments (COLAs) over time. Since COLAs are a percentage of your benefits, a higher base amount means a larger dollar increase when COLAs are applied. This can further widen the gap between early claimers and those who wait, amplifying the financial advantages.

SPONSORED WISERADVISOR

Need a financial advisor? Compare vetted advisors matched to your specific requirements.

Choosing the right financial advisor is daunting, especially when there are thousands of financial advisors near you. We make it easy by matching you to vetted advisors that meet your unique needs. Matched advisors are all registered with FINRA/SEC. Click to compare vetted advisors now.

What can you do if you are reconsidering your decision to claim your Social Security benefits early?

Life’s uncertainties might lead some to rethink their initial decision to claim Social Security benefits. Fortunately, the system provides an opportunity to do a do-over, but it’s essential to be aware of the stipulations and implications of such choices.

If you’ve recently started receiving Social Security benefits and are having second thoughts about your decision, you might be in luck. The Social Security Administration permits individuals to withdraw their benefits application, but this option comes with the following conditions:

1. You can only withdraw your application once in a lifetime.
2. The withdrawal must be made within 12 months of the date you first started receiving benefits.
3. All the benefits you and any family members received based on your application must be repaid in full, including any money withheld, for example, for Medicare premium deductions or taxes.
4. Once the benefits are repaid, it’s as though the initial application never happened, which means your benefits will continue to grow, allowing for a potentially larger monthly amount when you decide to claim them in the future.

If you’ve successfully withdrawn your application and repaid the benefits, you’re free to restart your benefits at any future date. This can be beneficial for those who find new employment or receive a financial windfall after initially filing for benefits. By waiting and claiming at a later age, your monthly benefit amount can increase due to both the absence of early retirement reductions and the potential accumulation of Delayed Retirement Credits.

However, for those who don’t officially withdraw their application but merely suspend benefits (an option available after reaching Full Retirement Age), benefits can be restarted at any time, and they will automatically resume at age 70 if not restarted sooner.

Tax considerations to keep in mind while claiming Social Security benefits

Navigating the Social Security system is only one aspect of retirement planning. Another important aspect is the associated tax implications. Being mindful of the tax outgo can maximize the net income you receive when you claim the benefits.

Below are some factors that you should consider when evaluating the taxability of your Social Security benefits:

1. The concept of “combined income” and how it affects your taxes

When the IRS evaluates the taxability of your Social Security benefits, it uses a formula centered on your “combined income.” This figure is the sum of your adjusted gross income (AGI), any non-taxable interest, and half of your Social Security benefits. Depending on the total, a portion of your Social Security benefits may be taxable:

For individual filers: If your combined income is between $25,000 and $34,000, up to 50% of your benefits may be taxable. If it’s more than $34,000, up to 85% of your benefits could be taxable.

For joint filers: If you and your spouse have a combined income between $32,000 and $44,000, up to 50% of your benefits might be taxable. If it’s over $44,000, up to 85% could be taxable.

It’s worth noting that these thresholds are not adjusted for inflation, so over time, more retirees may find a portion of their benefits becoming taxable if these limits remain static.

2. The tax implications of continuing to work

If you choose to continue working while receiving Social Security benefits before reaching your FRA, not only will your benefits be temporarily reduced due to earning limits set by the Social Security Administration, but your additional income could also make more of your benefits taxable. This is especially true if your additional earnings push your combined income into a higher taxable range.

Moreover, even after reaching FRA, while the Social Security earnings limits no longer apply, your continued income from employment could still impact the taxability of your Social Security benefits based on the “combined income” criteria mentioned above.

Thus, an informed approach, possibly with guidance from a tax professional, can help you make the most of your benefits and minimize the impact of taxes.

To conclude

Deciding when to file for Social Security benefits is a decision that holds weight for many, often serving as an important aspect in one’s retirement planning. It’s clear that while there are general principles and strategies to consider, the optimal choice truly hinges on an individual’s unique circumstances.

Most financial experts advise banking on the potential advantages of delaying benefits. By waiting beyond one’s full retirement age, individuals stand to gain significantly higher monthly benefits, which can prove beneficial in the long run, especially if one enjoys a longer-than-average lifespan. However, while the financial upside of delaying is evident, it’s equally crucial to weigh this against immediate financial needs and other personal factors.

Given the complexities and individualized nature of this decision, seeking professional advice can be invaluable. A financial advisor or retirement planner can provide tailored recommendations based on your financial situation, health, life expectancy, and future goals. Their insights can help navigate the intricacies of the Social Security system and ensure that you make a choice that aligns best with your long-term objectives.

Use the free advisor match service to match with vetted financial advisors who can advise you on when to claim your Social Security benefits while also providing other suitable retirement savings strategies. Answer a few basic questions based on your financial needs, and our matching tool can connect you with 2 to 3 advisors who can best fulfill your financial requirements.