Comparing Retirement Plans: Defined Benefit Vs Defined Contribution - Retirement Planning

While planning for your retirement, you may need to choose between a defined benefit plan versus a defined contribution plan. This choice necessitates careful consideration of numerous factors, such as employment types, tax liabilities, financial goals, and personal preferences. Making the right selection requires a thorough understanding of the key differences between both types of retirement plans.

In simpler terms, a defined benefit plan ensures retirees receive a steady and guaranteed income throughout their retirement years, while a defined contribution plan allows individuals to regularly contribute a portion of their earnings to a retirement savings account. Defined plans are considered low-risk and emphasize long-term stability. On the other hand, defined contribution plans aim to achieve higher investment returns and take advantage of compounding over time. The choice between the two may also be influenced by employment type and the retirement plans offered by various organizations. Consult with a professional financial advisor to understand the pros and cons of defined benefit and defined contribution retirement plans and to know which of the two plans would suit your financial needs and goals.

This article explores the nuances of defined benefit vs. defined contribution plans, as well as their benefits and drawbacks, so you can make an informed decision.

What are defined benefit plans?

A defined benefit plan is a retirement pension scheme in which employers promise to provide their employees with a specific, pre-determined income during their retirement years. This type of plan may even specify the exact dollar payout (for instance, $200 or $300 per month) after retirement. The benefits are determined based on complex formulas and factors like an employee’s salary history, years served, and more. This plan ensures a secure retirement for employees, as they receive a guaranteed pension amount. Public sector pensions, civil servant pensions, and traditional corporate pensions are all part of defined benefit plans.

Payments from a defined benefit plan can either be made as a lump sum or as an annuity, where the pension is disbursed monthly. Do note that the major responsibility and risk lies with the employer, who is required to manage the fund’s investments to meet future obligations. To safeguard against unforeseen financial challenges, employers often opt for insurance coverage to guarantee the promised benefits.

Although defined benefit plans have become less common in recent years due to their financial complexities and costs, they continue to provide employees with valuable and reliable retirement options.

What are the advantages of defined benefit plans?

Defined benefit plans offer several key advantages that make them an attractive retirement option. These are:

1. Offer a guaranteed income stream in retirement

Defined benefit plans provide a stable and predictable income stream throughout retirement. Retirees can rest assured that their pension will remain unaffected by market fluctuations, providing them with a sense of financial security and peace of mind.

2. Offer protection against outliving your retirement savings

With lifelong income provided by the plan, retirees do not have to worry about running out of funds during their retirement years. This longevity protection ensures a steady standard of living and financial stability well into old age.

3. Employers must choose investments and ensure there are sufficient funds in the plan

The burden of investment risks and administrative costs lies with the employer in defined benefit plans. Employers are responsible for managing the plan’s investments and ensuring sufficient funds to meet pension obligations. This relieves employees of the need to make complex investment decisions and places the onus on the employer to fulfill their retirement commitments.

What are the disadvantages of defined benefit plans?

1. Higher administrative costs than other retirement plans

Defined benefit plans have higher administrative costs compared to other retirement options. The complexity involved in managing these plans contributes to the increased expenses, which may impact the overall returns received by retirees.

2. Limited control over investment decisions

Additionally, individuals enrolled in defined benefit plans have limited control over their investment strategy. They are dependent on their employer’s management decisions, which might not align with their personal financial goals or risk tolerance.

What are defined contribution plans?

A defined contribution plan is a retirement scheme that requires both the employee and employer to make regular contributions towards the employee’s retirement savings.

Unlike defined benefit plans, the risk and responsibility for managing the investments in a defined contribution plan are transferred to the employee. This means that the eventual retirement income will depend on the choice of plan, the performance of the invested funds, contribution amounts, and more. The most popular defined contribution plans are 401(k)s, IRAs, 403(b)s, 457 plans, and Thrift Savings Plans (TSPs). Most of these plans allow for individual control of asset selection and allocation and come with significant tax advantages.

Defined benefit plans primarily differ from defined contribution plans as the former does not guarantee a specific retirement income. This is because the onus of returns and management is shifted to the employee.

What are the advantages of defined contribution plans?

1. Offers more control over your choice of investments

You can select from a diverse range of investment options like stocks, mutual funds, bonds, and more based on your risk tolerance and financial goals. If you are able to make successful investment choices, you can accumulate a significant corpus to support your retirement lifestyle.

2. Offers flexibility of switching retirement plans

Defined contribution plans offer flexibility to their account holders. When changing jobs, employees can carry their retirement accounts with them and continue managing their funds independently. They can also switch to a different plan to reduce their taxability. This flexibility ensures that employees can maintain their retirement savings’ growth trajectory even if they switch employers.

What are the disadvantages of defined contribution plans?

1. Your retirement savings may vary

The uncertainty of retirement income is a concern, as the final payout is subject to market fluctuations.

2. The onus of choosing and managing investments is on the employees

In defined contribution retirement plans, the employees bear the responsibility of managing their investments. Individuals who lack the requisite financial knowledge and expertise may find it difficult to make complex investment decisions. This may lead to losses and potentially not having enough savings during retirement years.

A summary of defined benefit versus defined contribution plans

Factors of Comparison	Defined Benefit Plans	Defined Contribution Plans
Funding responsibility	Employer-funded	Both employee and employer contributions
Retirement income	Provides a guaranteed income for life.	Income is based on contributions, type of plan, and market conditions.
Predictability	Offers predictable retirement benefits.	Income may fluctuate based on market performance.
Investment control	Employers manage investments.	Employees can select and manage investments.
Bearing of risks and costs	The employer bears investment and longevity risks.	Shifts investment and longevity risks to employees.
Benefit calculation method	Based on a formula considering several factors like salary, years of service, and certain projections.	Accumulated contributions and investment returns determine retirement benefits.
Portability and flexibility	Limited portability between employers	Offers portability and flexibility when shifting jobs.
Regulatory Compliance	Subject to strict government regulations and oversight.	Compliance with government regulations and plan rules required.

Defined benefit plan vs. defined contribution plans: Which one should you choose?

When choosing between defined benefit plans and defined contribution plans, the person’s age, personal circumstances, goals, etc., play a vital role. Younger individuals with longer investment horizons often find defined contribution plans appealing due to the tremendous potential for compounding returns over time. By leveraging these plans, they can maximize their savings and capitalize on long-term growth opportunities. On the other hand, older individuals nearing retirement may tend to prioritize the security offered by defined benefit plans. With these plans, they can receive a fixed income stream upon retirement, ensuring long-term financial security.

Another crucial factor in choosing between defined benefit and contribution plans is an individual’s risk tolerance. Investors who prefer stability and are risk-averse may lean towards defined benefit plans, which offer a predictable income stream. However, those more comfortable with high risks and seeking higher potential returns may favor defined contribution plans. In both cases, however, it is still important to thoroughly understand the levels of risk associated.

Do remember that different industries and organizations may provide specific retirement plan types, potentially limiting the choices available to the employees. As a result, it becomes imperative for each person to thoroughly understand their personal financial goals and circumstances and align them with the available employer-offered retirement plans.

To conclude

Defined benefit plans and defined contribution plans are two distinct retirement options. A defined benefit plan offers a fixed income stream upon retirement, appealing to individuals seeking stability and predictability in their retirement income. On the other hand, defined contribution plans allow individuals to contribute regularly to their retirement savings, providing potential for long-term growth and attracting those comfortable with investment risks. The choice between defined contribution versus a defined benefit pension plan will largely depend on one’s risk appetite, age, and preference for immediate financial security versus long-term growth opportunities. It may be wise to seek advice from a financial advisor who can conduct a comprehensive analysis of your financial situation and risk appetite to recommend the right retirement plan for your specific needs and goals.

Use the free advisor match service to get matched with an advisor who can help you choose a suitable retirement plan. Answer a few basic questions about your financial needs, and get matched to 1-3 vetted advisors that are best suited to help you with your specific requirements.